astronomy, space exploration, telescopes

 

Comparing Telescopes
      A telescope has often been called a "light bucket," as its purpose is to collect as much light as possible.  This is done by increasing the aperture, but as the aperture increases in size, so must the length of the tube.  In the late 1600's, two of the early astronomers, Huygens and Hevelius, in their quest to see more of our Universe, built telescopes up to 200 feet long.  A major problem with such large telescopes was the fact that the edges of a lens are much thinner than the center.  As it become larger, it becomes heavier and increasingly difficult to mount.  The world's largest refractor telescope was built in 1897 at Yerkes Observatory in Wisconsin.  It has a lens diameter of forty inches and is still in use today.  It is at the upper limit of size at which a refract telescope can be structurally stable.  If its lens were any heavier, it could not be supported around its edges by current technology.
     A reflector telescope does not suffer from this limitation because its uses a mirror to collect light, rather than a lens; thus they can be quite large.  The telescopes used by all the great observatories use this design.  The world's largest is the Keck Telescope at Mauna Kea Observatory in Hawaii.  It was build with a 394 inch diameter mirror and has been operational since 1991.
     A refractor telescope certainly fills the needs of budding astronomers, but as skill and knowledge increase, they want to probe deeper and deeper into the secrets of the Universe, and this can only be done with a telescope having a large aperture.  Per inch of aperture, reflector telescopes cost significantly less than refractor telescopes.   
Galileo Refractor Newton Reflector
Aperture Lens collects light Mirror collects light
Viewing moon, planets and Sun Excellent Good
Viewing deep space - galaxies, nebula, etc. Good Excellent
Terrestrial Viewing Good Not suitable
Ease of  Use Very Easy Less Easy
Reliability Very sturdy More fragile
Maintenance Minimal to None Required
Large Aperture Scopes Bulky and Heavy Compact and light
Cost per inch of aperture higher lower